Scaffolding the Process of Moving From Reading a Text to Analyzing It
This three-step process uses thinking routines from Project Zero to guide high school students to begin writing an argumentative or analytical essay.
Your content has been saved!
Go to My Saved Content.One of the most challenging and circuitous activities in high school English language arts (ELA) is when a student transitions from reading a text to writing an argumentative or analytical essay about a text.
Thankfully, there’s great work happening at the Harvard Graduate School of Education’s (GSE’s) Project Zero, which I’ve found to be a helpful resource in my own English classroom. I’ve gathered three thinking routines developed by the Harvard GSE that, sequenced together, can scaffold a student’s journey from reading, to writing about a reading, to reflecting on the entire process.
Here are the three routines, broken down into steps.
Step One: A Routine for Close Reading with See, Think, Wonder
Students can’t effectively write about a text they don’t understand, and yet, close reading advice is often tantamount to “try harder.” The “see, think, wonder” thinking routine is an effective antidote. It’s versatile and works with written texts that are both long and short. I first came across it while examining artwork as a part of a Smithsonian American Art Museum workshop on incorporating visual art into the broader curriculum.
The see step of the routine asks students to simply list the things they notice. Take William Blake’s poem “A Poison Tree,” for instance. With the poem projected on the board, a teacher might ask the class about literal details (“When the narrator of the poem hides his anger, it causes a tree to grow in his garden”), or they might ask for impressions (“The rhyming couplets throughout remind me of a poem for children.”)
Patiently waiting for students to exhaust their poetry observations is key. Teachers should keep the focus on facts and impressions before students move on to making meaning out of those facts and impressions. This mental routine is the sort of thing that students learn to repeat on their own.
Once the board is covered with facts and impressions, the teacher should prompt students to begin the think step of the routine. A student might say something like, “I think the poem is about how not expressing your emotions can make them more intense.” The teacher can respond by literally drawing a line from facts and impressions to this new insight. For students who feel mystified by how their classmates come up with new insights, the think portion of the activity—moving from details to insights and themes—can be an enormous help.
We want our students to engage with complex texts, which brings us to wonder, the final step of the routine. Here, students consider aspects of the work that still feel unexplained or unexamined. Students might note that the whole class has yet to come up with an insight about why the tree that seemingly represents the narrator’s anger bears fruit, or why it bears an apple, but not an orange or a pear. The wonder step cues students toward areas of further exploration, modeling a transition from details to insights over and over until a significant pattern emerges.
Step Two: From Insight to Argument with Claim, Support, Question
After students progress past close reading, teachers should next encourage the “claim, support, question” routine. Teachers can contrast this routine with “see, think, wonder” by asking students to consider the difference in scale between thoughts and claims about a work.
During “see, think, wonder,” a student might say the “A Poison Tree” poem made them think it’s dangerous to hold on to your anger, and wonder why the narrator’s foe is the person lying dead at the end of the poem. After all, it’s the narrator who’s seemingly consumed by hatred.
After completing that exploration, the same student is ready to make a claim about the meaning of the entire poem. (Typically, a claim will engage with multiple facets of a work, not just one section or stanza.) Once again, the teacher can lead students by recording the class’s findings on the board. But this time, the teacher asks students to move directly from claim to support, rather than patiently waiting for the rest of the class to share their claims as well.
After a few students share their respective claims and support, the teacher can open up the question step by asking the class to look for gaps in logic, as well as unanswered questions and counterarguments. By the end of this step, students are ready to start writing.
Step Three: From Product to Metacognition with ‘I Used to Think, Now I Think…’
Once students have developed strong claims backed by thorough support from the text, teachers can guide them through the process of drafting, revising, and editing their written argument or analysis essay. But teachers should recognize that metacognition—reflecting on how one thinks and learns—is as important as the actual thinking products that students produce. So after students have received teacher feedback on their essays, they should transition to step three: I used to think, now I think…
Unlike the previous routines, which include large-group discussions while the teacher records the class’s ideas, I used to think, now I think… is better suited for individual reflection via journaling (or small-group talks). Teachers can provide significant structure to this routine with modeling. Two examples:
- Teachers model how to reflect on the content of a learning experience: “I used to think anger was just like any other emotion, but now I think…”
- Teachers model the thinking process itself: “I used to think I would figure out my ideas once I sat down to write, but now I think sharing with others along the way makes my ideas stronger.”
Teachers usually add other stipulations, but keeping the I used to think, now I think… routine at the center of any reflection reminds students that learning, not a specific grade, is the ultimate goal of their schoolwork.
Taken together, the three aforementioned routines go great with traditional accountability tools like reading checks and chunking the writing process, etc. These routines are simple, memorable, and easily repeatable; they ensure that everyone in a classroom is actively engaged in critical thinking, which leads to self-regulated readers and writers.
